Virtualization Pro

Feb 23 2009   9:19PM GMT

VMware ESX for free? The heat is on

Eric Siebert Eric Siebert Profile: Eric Siebert

Now that Citrix is giving away the XenServer hypervisor for free (albeit sans advanced features), is it time for VMware to follow suit by giving away the base edition of VMware ESX as it did with ESXi?

In my open letter to VMware last month, one of my points was that VMware should give away ESX. It is the exact same hypervisor as ESXi with a few minor differences. Architecturally the main difference between the two is that ESX comes with the full service console and ESXi comes with the limited Posix-based BusyBox management console. The full service console that comes with ESX is useful for running scripts and other management functions but is not essential for VM operations and administration.

You can see from the below graphic the different editions of VMware ESX and what features come with each of them.

VI Editions

All of the editions allow you to use ESXi instead of ESX if you choose to do so. Currently the Foundation edition of both ESX and ESXi (which is the base version) includes a vCenter Server agent and support for Update Manager and Consolidated Backup. So why not give a base edition of ESX away for free and not include those components? If someone wants the more advanced features then they can upgrade to the other editions. Or why not take it a step further and include the vCenter agent, Update Manager and Consolidated Backup with the free version?

If VMware gave away ESX and included High Availability, VMware’s free product would be one step ahead of Citrix’s.

So how will VMware make any money if it gives away more of its products for free? First, having the aforementioned add-on features available for free would require anyone that wants to use them to purchase vCenter Server, which is necessary for them to work.

VMware can charge for users that want the vMotion/Storage vMotion and Distrubuted Resource Scheduler and Distributed Power Management features which most enterprises are going to want. It can also charge for vCenter Server which is a must have in all large environments. Additionally, VMware has many more automation and management products that it can sell, not to mention support subscriptions for all of its products.

In the increasing competitive virtualization arena, VMware needs to do more then just have a better product to attract and retain customers. Most companies are concerned about cost, and with other vendors giving away their products VMware needs to do the same thing. Giving away ESX and some basic features will help them to compete and eliminate the cost arguments that other vendors are constantly making when comparing their product to VMware’s.

3  Comments on this Post

There was an error processing your information. Please try again later.
Thanks. We'll let you know when a new response is added.
Send me notifications when other members comment.
  • CJGarrett
    The problem here is when you give something away for free, it is worth nothing to the recipient. By giving away a core product, VMware would be devaluing the market that they've created. VMware should realise that they own this market; it's not like they need to win back huge chunks of market share by sacrificing their and their partners' profits. If ESX was given away to the masses, consulting opportunities would dry up, and VMware would find that the sales of the rest of their product line would also grind to a halt. Why go out for Filet Mignon when you can have a burger at home? In Australia, VMware has made huge numbers of ESX licenses available to Universities and Government bodies. So while it's true that they can now claim that they have huge penetration into these markets, it's also true to say that this has ruined two sources of revenue for their resellers.
    0 pointsBadges:
  • Eric Siebert
    But they are already giving away a core product in ESXi, it's the same Hypervisor as ESX. Wouldn't consulting opportunities increase if they also gave ESX away? There would be more people needing help with properly installing and configuring it. The problem with ESX & ESXi are they are really too easy to install and almost anyone can do it but many times it is not configured properly which it takes experience to do. Additionally it may drive more people to take classes to learn how to install and configure it.
    1,830 pointsBadges:
  • CJGarrett
    Getting training on a product is an easier sell to your boss or CIO if he's already financially committed to that product. Try asking a CIO or CFO to budget training for a free product. More often than not, they'd rather you put in extra time Googling or just hacking away. It's precisely because ESXi is given away that we're seeing very low levels of take up in the enterprises we deal with, and then it is being used in non critical areas like test & dev. Management do not place any value on a free product.
    0 pointsBadges:

Forgot Password

No problem! Submit your e-mail address below. We'll send you an e-mail containing your password.

Your password has been sent to:

Share this item with your network: