Collisions in network cable

1545 pts.
Network cable
Packet Design
I still get collisions on one of my network cables even when I have a switch. Is this to do with the cable I'm using? What can I do?

Answer Wiki

Thanks. We'll let you know when a new response is added.

From Carrie Higbie, Ask the Expert ,
I would also try moving to another switch port. I would also check to see that the switch port is set to full duplex. You can call a cabling installer and have them test the cable for you that should rule out the horizontal part of the cable and both patch cords. If the cabling tests and passes (which I believe it won’t) then it will be in your electronics. But more than likely the cable is faulty or the NIC card or switch port is faulty. In the past we used to have to set switch ports to 10Mb half duplex for some applications. If you are running half duplex you will have collisions.

From BuddyFarr
if you take the workstation to another connection on the same network does it still do this? if not I would suspect the patch cable on either end or the horizontal cabling, (cable in wall between wall jack and wiring closet). If it still happens it could be the NIC in the workstation, the drivers for the NIC or badly written software that you are using. What software are you using when this happens? Depending on how much data you are pushing across the wire you can still get some collisions. Does it happen all the time? Is the collision light on the switch lit constantly?

From jmkelly:
Collisions aren’t the end of the world. Rich Seifert, one of the developers of the original Ethernet protocol, used to say he wished they’d never used that word, but called them something like “medium access arbitration events.” Even in a perfectly functional Ethernet LAN, collisions will happen; they happen whenever two hosts try to talk at once, which is going to happen with a non-deterministic protocol. (If you really hate collisions, dump Ethernet and run Token Ring!) Following a collision, each host backs off and tries again later, thus keeping congestion *on the edges of the network*, which is the whole purpose of the “collision” part of the protocol. The question is not whether you’re getting collisions; it’s whether you’re getting all the bandwidth the equipment
is supposed to provide?
BTW, cable faults can’t cause collisions. They might cause dropped frames and retransmissions,
which might lead to collisions, but then lots of things can cause drops and retransmissions.

Discuss This Question: 1  Reply

There was an error processing your information. Please try again later.
Thanks. We'll let you know when a new response is added.
Send me notifications when members answer or reply to this question.
  • Snapper70
    Your best bet, actually, is to be CONSISTENT about speeds/duplex for workstations. Locking a workstation port on a switch to 100Full is typically a mistake, especially where a laptop is involved. IF you set to 100Full, you then have to set the workstation to 100Full as well, otherwise the laptop will wind up negotiating 100 half. If you then set 100Full on the workstation, then you have to make sure ALL ports you plug into (including home routers) are set to 100Full as well. For generic workstation ports, best to have switches AND PC's autonegotiate.
    920 pointsBadges:

Forgot Password

No problem! Submit your e-mail address below. We'll send you an e-mail containing your password.

Your password has been sent to:

To follow this tag...

There was an error processing your information. Please try again later.

Thanks! We'll email you when relevant content is added and updated.


Share this item with your network: