IT Trenches

Mar 21 2010   4:42PM GMT

Book Review: CISSP Video Mentor by Shon Harris

Troy Tate Profile: Troy Tate

Shon Harris is a well known author of information security training materials. She is the owner and president of Logical Security. I recently had the opportunity to go through her CISSP Video Mentor course presented by Pearson Learning. This product can be found on Amazon for a price of $53.55 at the time of this writing. It can also be found on InformIT for the much higher price or $76.50. If you are a socially conscious buyer and want to promote world literacy, then consider buying this product and any future book purchases at BetterWorldBooks. BetterWorldBooks has this selection for $56.98. The product is actually a DVD with an 80 page book (of which only 43 pages are content and the remainder are blank pages for notes).

I have been through several certification programs using both classroom and self-study. I definitely like the idea of self-study with good study materials that take complex topics and make them easy to understand. This Video Mentor product is a reasonably good self-study tool for making complex topics and simplifying them for students. Before I describe the contents, I need to raise a frustration with the product right from the start. The presentations are all in Adobe Flash Video (flv) format. When you put the DVD into your computer and the autorun starts the program (don’t get me started on autorun on removable media!), you may be presented with the message shown below.

This was rather frustrating to me as I tried to run this on a couple of laptops that were new within the past 3 years but not capable of the screen resolution described. What this means is when you watch the video presentations as presented by the videomentor.exe player, you do not have visibility of any player controls like pause, fast forward, reverse or time remaining. I would like to be able to pause a presentation or know how long it will last.

There are a couple of workarounds that I used to get past this real frustration. One workaround is available right on the DVD itself. There is an html file called videomentor.html. You can open this file in any browser at any resolution. The content will be shown with scrollbars on the side and bottom of the browser window as needed. This allows the viewer to see the controls at the bottom of the presentation in the browser window. However, this can be annoying to have to scroll for access to video controls.

The second workaround I used was downloading a standalone FLV player. I tried both the Sothink Media FLV player and the Wimpy FLV player. The training materials showed well in both players and it was a great improvement to have access to the video controls missing due to being unable to meet the material’s display requirements. This is something that Pearson Learning and other training product material production companies need to consider.

Now on to the content of the product. There are six sections as shown below with a “lab” section for each one except Lesson 1: Cryptography Foundations.

The reason I put “lab” in quotes is this product presents labs differently than I expected. I expected a lab to be something with a list of tasks described in the printed materials for the student to complete and document the results of the tasks. This presentation uses the labs to do a deeper dive into the materials shown in that section. In other words, the presenter takes steps of using a linux box to show how to encrypt and hash files. This is all well and good, but the labs should also have the steps documented in the book for students to use after the video is over. I feel the book is not a good support to the extensive materials presented in the videos. I realize the product is called Video Mentor but the issue with the video controls presented earlier and the lack of documentation on the lab procedures left me wondering if this product could really be an effective learning tool.

The topics presented focus on some of the more technically challenging aspects of the CISSP certification. I cannot speak to how well the materials actually match up with CISSP objectives. I can speak though on how I perceive the product can meet the needs of a technology student. The CISSP exam covers ten domains listed below.

Access Control Systems & Methodology
Applications & Systems Development
Business Continuity Planning
Law, Investigation & Ethics
Operations Security
Physical Security
Security Architecture & Models
Security Management Practices
Telecommunications, Network & Internet Security

As you can see, the list of the ten CISSP domains does not seem to closely match the focus of the CISSP Video Mentor product. The Video Mentor product appears to focus on only two of the ten domains, Cryptography and Telecommunications, Network & Internet Security. I think the product covers Cryptography to a pretty good level of detail, and this alone might be worth investing in the product. Cryptography, asymmetric encryption, public-private key encryption are all difficult to understand. Any training material that tries to make this more understandable is, in my opinion, worth a deeper look.

Where this product seems to miss the boat on its objectives is related to the Telecommunications, Network & Internet Security domain. The order of the presentations is confusing. It seems like it would be a better idea to present the OSI 7-layer model before discussing IP-SEC and network traffic encryption. For me, the 802.11 Wireless section was eye-glazing. The presenter, Don Keeber, had a very level voice and presented without personality. I did not get much out of this section and do not feel that it added anything significant to the product.

Bottom line on this I would rate the product 2 1/2 stars out of 4. The technical player issues and the missing lab documentation do not justify a higher rating on a product from Pearson Learning or Shon Harris. I do think there are some good nuggets in here on describing concepts of encryption methods and that alone might make it worth adding to your library. I would recommend looking around and finding the best price on the product. No need to pay list price. If you do have this product, or get it at some point, please share your thoughts with me and other ITKE readers.

Thanks for reading and let’s continue to be good network citizens.

 Comment on this Post

There was an error processing your information. Please try again later.
Thanks. We'll let you know when a new response is added.
Send me notifications when other members comment.

Forgot Password

No problem! Submit your e-mail address below. We'll send you an e-mail containing your password.

Your password has been sent to:

Share this item with your network: