February 17, 2010 9:34 PM
Posted by: Linda Tucci
Ahh, the irony! Organizations that have been through some kind of a disaster certainly understand the value of business continuity plans. But for most everybody else?
“When you talk about having a plan that could cost $20,000, $50,000 or $100,000, and might sit on a shelf and gather dust, for most business leaders, it’s ‘Excuse me, I have a business to run,’” said Paul Kirvan, a business continuity consultant based in New Jersey.
I heard a lot of variations on that attitude in my reporting this week for a story on mapping key risk indicators and key performance indicators in order to prove the value of business continuity (BC) programs. BC plans are a tough sell and not only because of those business leaders who’d rather spend money on making money.
The field is young — only about 35 years old, Kirvan told me. And the tools of the trade are not all that sophisticated. Quantifying the impact of a business-disrupting event that hasn’t happened, in order to craft a sound plan for getting back to business, is a soft science.
So soft, in fact, that Ramon Krikken, an analyst with Burton Group, has found that anecdotes about the bad things that have happened to other companies — good, old-fashioned horror stories — continue to be among the more powerful tools continuity specialists possess for convincing upper management that business continuity plans hold value.
In the United States there’s another element at play that makes it hard to get funding for BC — what Kirvan calls the “cultural dimension.”
Business continuity is viewed differently in the U.K. and other European countries from the way it is here, said Kirvan, who has worked extensively in the United Kingdom and is also a board member of the Business Continuity Institute. Of course, Great Britain is the source of arguably the industry’s most accepted business continuity standard, BS 25999. But it’s not just a matter of standards or certification, he said.
“The culture over [in the UK] tends to be one of anticipating potential problems,” he said. Business continuity is taken seriously, he said, perhaps because of issues with the IRA over the years and more recently, the 2007 terrorist bombings.
“Our culture, by contrast, with the pioneer spirit, that can-do, ‘We can handle anything, just throw it at us’ attitude, doesn’t take that view,” Kirvan said. American businesses are focused on the present and tend to believe the future will always be brighter.
“The typical reaction I have seen over the years from American businesses is that, ‘Well, we have never had a major issue, why should we worry about it? We’ll deal with it when it occurs,’” he said.
What about at your company?
February 16, 2010 8:10 PM
Posted by: Christina Torode
, Disaster recovery
Many large companies try to maintain hot sites that are in lockstep with the production environment, but this disaster recovery plan isn’t always realistic.
Configurations drift, or IT staff simply don’t have the time — or the budget — to mirror every aspect of their production environment. That’s where virtualization comes in.
Applications that may not have made it on the mission-critical DR list can now be put on a shared piece of hardware: a virtual server in the data center or hot site. The costs of maintaining hardware for both mission-critical and not-so-critical applications can drop considerably in this scenario.
The other day, Nelson Ruest, a principal with consulting firm Resolutions Enterprises Ltd., in Victoria, British Columbia, was telling me that one of his enterprise clients is projecting 60% to 70% savings, per year, across its infrastructure for disaster recovery. The company moved from mirroring the production environment — taking up three floors to do so in its backup data center — to using less floor space and hardware with a virtualized DR plan. It replaced many physical servers with virtual servers in its production environment as well.
Independent Bank, out of Iona, Mich., saved $1 million in hardware by replacing underutilized hardware with virtual servers, as part of a desktop-to-data-center virtualization DR strategy.
The shift to virtual desktops and servers allowed the bank to eliminate configuration drift between its hot site and production environment as well, according to its CIO, Pete Graves.
Still, enterprises are hesitant to use virtual disaster recovery for mission-critical applications, and are definitely not throwing out tape backups any time soon, according to John Humphreys, senior director of product marketing for the virtualization and management division of Citrix Systems Inc.
Humphreys is seeing the spread of virtualization for DR take the same path that the technology did on the server front: around the edges of the enterprise, starting with non-mission-critical applications that haven’t made it into the “critical” DR budget.
Others believe that virtualization DR will continue to evolve as server virtualization does. As the staff at SearchServerVirtualization.com point out in an article on predictions for 2010, there is still the potential for one virtual server to take down hundreds of other virtual machines with it.
So, it would seem that enterprises are testing out and moving forward with virtualization disaster recovery, but with a note of caution.
Tell us what your disaster recovery plans are and if virtualization will be part of them. Email firstname.lastname@example.org.
February 15, 2010 4:56 PM
Posted by: Rachel Lebeaux
, CIO weekly wrap-up
Why, yes, I am working on President’s Day — are you? When I logged on this morning after a mostly-offline weekend, I discovered that people are still buzzing about privacy issues related to Google Buzz. Google has issued a mea culpa, and says it is replacing the “auto-follow” feature (which, in turn, revealed the people whom you email most frequently using Gmail) with an “auto-suggest” feature that lets you pick your followers yourself. And, with that news, my personal foray into Google Buzz will begin….
So, as you Gmailers set up your latest social-networking venture, take a few minutes to peek at the latest stories from SearchCIO.com:
New IT management framework focuses on business value – Enterprises such as Chevron and Merck are working together to shape an emerging IT-management best practices framework. Could this work in your organization?
IT outsourcing strategy FAQ: Outsourcing and offshoring – An IT outsourcing strategy is crucial to enterprises looking to cut costs and globalize operations during a recession. In this guide, learn how to get started with IT outsourcing, and feel free to let us know if there are other IT outsourcing questions you would like to see addressed in this format.
Implementing Lean methodologies promotes IT, business agility – Implementing Lean methodologies helps IT organizations eliminate wasteful processes and promote IT and business agility, our CIO columnist says. Read more about Niel Nickolaisen’s approach to implementing Lean here.
How to automate and improve business processes, Las Vegas style – Business process automation remains a high priority for CIOs. In this piece, Sin City’s CIO and inveterate business process improver shares his thought on what works.
February 12, 2010 3:51 PM
Posted by: Rachel Lebeaux
, CIO careers
, IT hiring
A few weeks ago, over a delicious dinner of Thai food with my uncle visiting from the Palo Alto area, I went on and on about my job here at SearchCIO.com and about all the various social media platforms on which my work now relies, including Twitter, LinkedIn and, of course, this blog.
As I slurped down the last of my to-die-for pad see ew noodles, I apologized for spending so much of our time together blabbing about this aspect of my work. My uncle just laughed.
“You’d be very popular in Silicon Valley,” he said. “This qualifies as a very normal conversation where I live.”
As home to the Googleplex and the launch pad of the dot-com boom in the late 1990s, Silicon Valley has long been reputed as a sort of Mecca for technology-minded businessmen and -women and the innovative IT pros that support them — and the Silicon Valley economy has thrived on these industries. But this economic recession is causing some to wonder: How long will Silicon Valley tech companies remain the top dogs in IT?
In fact, Silicon Valley tech could be losing its edge, according to the 2010 Index of Silicon Valley report. The area lost 90,000 jobs from the second quarter of 2008 to the second quarter of 2009, and unemployment in Silicon Valley is higher than national levels, even worse than in 2005, when technology companies were still recovering from the dot-com bust of the early 2000s, reports The New York Times.
When these Silicon Valley tech companies do hire, they usually employ some brand of IT outsourcing, whether domestic or offshore. As we have reported on SearchCIO.com, companies are looking to run as lean as possible in 2010, with the aim of boosting profits while keeping expenditures relatively stable.
Although I haven’t heard of any heir apparent to Silicon Valley, I do wonder what will happen if the region doesn’t see a turnaround soon. There are fears that a prolonged downturn in Silicon Valley could cause a real brain drain. Already there is evidence that immigration to the region has declined, and questions about whether up-and-coming tech enthusiasts will be willing to pay inflated real estate prices — especially if their salaries aren’t keeping up and layoffs loom as venture capital financing sinks.
The story’s final quote, from Judy Estrin, former CTO of Cisco Systems Inc., was perhaps the most telling:
“Silicon Valley is both a barometer of the rest of the country and a spark for the rest of the country, and if we don’t protect that innovation culture here, it’s going to be hard to sustain an innovation culture in the country.”
I’ll be keeping an eye on the Silicon Valley economy’s continued struggles not only via Thai food fests with my uncle, but thanks to contact with our CIO readers as well. To be sure, these are troubling times for IT, even at the industry’s epicenter.
February 10, 2010 9:24 PM
Posted by: Linda Tucci
, CIO careers
, IT PMO
Ten minutes after filing a story on the virtues of an enterprise project management office, I got a call from a CIO I’d gotten to know over the years informing me that he had been fired. On a Friday afternoon. No explanations given, except that his position was being eliminated. The company in question is a well-known brand name. From what I heard, 2010 promises to be as challenging for this company as 2009, if not more so. IT is viewed as cost center; costs had to be cut. The powers that be went after the biggest salary.
One of the hallmarks of this CIO’s five-year tenure was his setting up a project management office (PMO), with the laudable aim of bringing order, transparency and business participation to IT projects. Given his starting point — IT run amok — it was a hard slog. By the time I profiled his work, however, a formal process — rather than the squeaky wheel — determined which IT projects got done and when.
I don’t know why the CIO got axed (not sure he does either), but his situation got me thinking about whether there is a dark side to PMOs.
If a CIO goes to the trouble of embedding IT in the business so that IT is no longer the mysterious dark art many business people see it as, is he engineering himself out of a job?
“Of course you are,” was the immediate response of the first employed CIO I asked, the head of IT for a big city government. But that is as it should be, he said. As cloud computing becomes the norm, a CIO’s main job will be to plot strategy and manage the various vendors. “There is no reason we should be building any of this stuff.”
His gloss on the matter? “The PMO does one thing very well, and it depends on your organization whether that is detrimental or positive: It exposes you. Everybody who has anything to do with the strategy of the company is in it. That means there are reports and documents, failures and recasts of projects, costs analyses. The thing about transparency is that it can either be a boon or a bust for you.”
February 9, 2010 5:45 PM
Posted by: Christina Torode
, IT salaries
, IT staff motivation
Sure, there are many IT professionals out there who are happy to just have a job; but as we move into 2010 and enterprises begin to dust off delayed projects, is your IT staff motivated enough to stay?
I ask because I just read the Dice Report for February, which shows that corporate HR and technology leaders are clearly out of sync when it comes to IT staff motivation.
When asked about the biggest blockade to motivating their IT staff, the No. 1 answer from HR was, “None, our technology team is motivated.”
Tech leaders polled in the same survey said salary freezes and smaller raises were the biggest impediments to IT staff motivation.
I’m not hearing much about pay raises yet from IT folks. In fact, our IT salary and career survey for 2009 showed that salaries decreased from 2008 to 2009, but 458 of the 952 IT executives and managers we surveyed do expect a pay raise of about 4.7% this year.
Where does this leave CIOs? If companies aren’t acknowledging pay raises as a key motivator, what else can they do to raise the mood in their IT departments?
Training and defining a career path for your IT staff come to mind. Your IT staff needs to keep pace with an ever-changing landscape; and the cost of training could be justified as not only a motivational tool, but ultimately as a revenue generator for the business.
In the same vein, our CIO columnist Niel Nickolaisen points to the importance of providing IT staff with meaningful work when salary increases are not an option.
So, if salary increases and possibly training are out of the budget for now, what are you doing to motivate your staff? Let me know at email@example.com
February 8, 2010 4:51 PM
Posted by: Rachel Lebeaux
, CIO weekly wrap-up
Super Bowl Sunday was yesterday, so let the Monday-morning quarterbacking begin! The turning point in the game was the Saints’ decision to go for that onsides kick at the beginning of the second half, yes? I don’t think the Colts ever recovered.
I imagine dissecting the Super Bowl is top of mind for many of you. According to CNN, high-tech kept the Super Bowl on track with instant replay and multiple camera angles of the Saints’ fourth-quarter two-point conversion (which was originally ruled no-good, then reversed).
For those less interested in the actual game, what did you think of the Super Bowl ads? Any favorites? Who else was surprised to see Google’s advertisement? A panel of MBA students from Northwestern University ranked it as the most effective ad of the night. (My other big surprise? Leno and Letterman in the same room.)
And, for some non-Super Bowl news, here are the latest stories from SearchCIO.com, covering IT salaries and careers, project management offices and surviving the recession.
IT salary survey shows no growth in 2009, but that could end in 2010 – A look back at IT executives’ state of mind and IT salaries for 2008 compared with our 2009 IT salary and careers survey.
Project management office helps CIO navigate rough financial waters – How did CIO Sharon Gietl help The Doe Run Co. navigate budget cuts and layoffs? With a tiny PMO that is prioritizing projects across the enterprise.
How to survive a recession using best practices in IT — Quiz time! Do you know how to survive a recession using best practices in IT cost management? In this enterprise CIO guide, review our latest stories and test your IQ on IT lessons learned.
2010 CIO and IT salaries and career survey: Read our special report – CIO and IT salaries are bouncing back in 2010 after a tough 2009. In this special report, learn about IT salaries by industry, CIO job tenures and more.
February 4, 2010 10:11 PM
Posted by: Rachel Lebeaux
, IT budgets
I can’t believe it’s already February (and thank goodness: I wouldn’t have been able to wait much longer for “Lost” to return!). Here at SearchCIO.com, even though a full month of 2010 is behind us, we’re still sorting through and reviewing 2009 IT lessons — “recession lessons,” if you will. This month’s CIO Briefing was a roundup of the results from our CIO and IT salaries and careers survey conducted in late 2009. I also put together a quiz to see if you’ve been paying attention to our recent coverage of technology-related recession lessons from 2009.
Why the long look back? I hate to be trite, but if you don’t learn history you’re doomed to repeat it — yes, CIOs, that includes you. A lot of desperate measures — or at least, that’s how they were viewed at the time — were put into place in IT organizations in the past year and a half. These included reduced IT staffing levels, an increased emphasis on business process management — you don’t need me to tell you, because you’re probably the one who had to make these difficult management decisions. I think we’re all looking forward to the day — maybe it will come later this year? — when IT budgets will loosen once again, allowing for the rededication of resources to IT, which can help move the entire business forward.
But if you enterprise CIOs go back to the old way of doing things once your budget dollars start trickling back, be warned that you’ll most likely be falling behind your peers. That’s because 2009 IT lessons will play a key role in dictating the future of IT.
The IT organization will always be charged with examining and implementing emerging technologies, but we’ve got to accomplish those “keeping the lights on” tasks quickly and efficiently, too. In all likelihood, business process automation will explode over the next few years as IT organizations find a cheaper way to complete this repetitive work. Business intelligence tools and dashboards will also be huge, as enterprise CIOs must keep track of an ever-widening playing field. IT outsourcing, which I covered quite a bit over the past year, will certainly make up a piece of the pie in replacing IT staffing without the salary commitments of the past.
What 2009 IT lessons are you carrying into your IT plans for 2010 — and beyond? Sound off below!
February 4, 2010 8:04 PM
Posted by: Linda Tucci
, IT management
It’s easy to forget how young a discipline IT is, given its enormous presence in our lives. Yesterday, however, that fact was front and center, as I watched the top IT talent at Intel Corp., Merck KGaA, BP PLC and Chevron Corp. talk about raising their “maturity levels.” Brilliant minds, and they’re talking about inching from Level 2 to Level 3 with the help of a new management IT framework called the IT-CMF, the Capability Maturity Framework.
The occasion was a morning presentation in downtown Boston by the Innovation Value Institute (IVI), a joint venture between Intel Corp., The Boston Consulting Group and the National University of Ireland, Maynooth. Established in 2006 and based in large part on the intellectual capital of Martin Curley of Intel, IVI’s mission, as the press material states, is “to tackle the universal problem of otherwise highly sophisticated companies ‘shooting in the dark’ on their IT investments.” The goal is to manage IT for business value.
News Editor Tina Torode will be writing in more detail about IT-CMF’s five-stage maturity framework, the end-to-end 36 IT processes it covers and its database of best practices culled from the insights of industry titans like Chevron, BP and Merck. Suffice it to say here that there was a lot of talk about assessments, establishing a baseline of maturity, drilldowns, identifying gaps, tapping into best practices. Oh, yes, and slide upon slide of charts with multicolored arrows to indicate the progression to maturity.
In one-on-one interviews after the slide presentations, some of the IVI presenters acknowledged the obvious: that the framework is young, that rounding out its database of best practices will realistically take more years and many more companies. Vincenzo Marchese, head of architecture capability and performance at BP, for example, said that while the framework addressed processes and delineated the underlying capabilities necessary to achieve a particular level of maturity, it did not cover people and tools much. Those 36 processes also could use some pruning, he said. But the framework, its disciples agreed, was a path to measuring whether the billions of dollars spent on IT are bringing an ROI for their funders. In addition, its emphasis on continuous improvement, an approach long embraced by business, was fundamental to helping IT mature.
Indeed, the emotional wallop for me, sitting in The Boston Consulting Group’s 31st-floor seminar room with magnificent views of the Boston Harbor, was how desperately IT wants to find a way to demonstrate its business value. IT, the Peter Pan of the commercial world, needs to grow up, in the eyes of these people. Maybe this IT-CMF framework will help.