TotalCIO

Jul 28 2008   2:17PM GMT

Cuil challenges Google’s supremacy



Posted by: Rachel Lebeaux
Tags:
Technologies

Will the best Internet search engine please stand up? In the eyes of many, that would be industry giant Google (like you even need a link).┬áBut there’s a new challenger today: Cuil, courtesy of Anna Patterson, a former Google employee who sold her Internet search engine technology to the industry giant in 2004 to upgrade its own system.

Now, Patterson intends to upstage Google (which she quit in 2006) with her new search engine, Cuil – pronounced “cool” (it’s an old Irish word for knowledge.)

According to the article, “rather than trying to mimic Google’s method of ranking the quantity and quality of links to websites, Patterson says Cuil’s technology drills into the actual content of a page. And Cuil’s results will be presented in a more magazine-like format instead of just a vertical stack of web links. Cuil’s results are displayed with more photos spread horizontally across the page and include sidebars that can be clicked on to learn more about topics related to the original search request.”

Of course, I had to check this out. The first thing I noticed is that the new site’s still very much under construction. I got error messages and/or broken image links when I clicked across several of the tabs at the top of the page. But I’m sure those boo-boos will be ironed out quickly.

I introduced myself to Cuil in the most narcissistic way possible: by searching my own name. I was notified that there were 144,900 results (I had no idea I was so popular) but, as I waited more than a minute for them to load, I nearly gave up … but then there they were.

Initial impressions? Maybe I’m just too used to the traditional “vertical stack” of results, but the “magazine-like format” didn’t really do it for me. There were images alongside some of the links, but most had little or nothing to do with the context of my name within the linked page.

What I did like was that some of the results were actually more relevant to me (i.e., links to actual articles I have written) than I often get with Google.

Here’s another thing I liked: when I typed CIO into Cuil, it returned 10.6 million results. But it also had them filtered by different topic tabs at the top of the page, including “Chief Information Officer” (which had 131,766 links), “AFL-CIO” and others. And the images were better matched to the result than in my previous search.

Google returned 19.2 million results on CIO. But how many of those relate to the chief information officer? As far as I can see, there’s no one-click way to tell you.

Still, at least on Day One, I have to agree with Gartner Inc. analyst Allen Weiner, who told CNNMoney.com that Google has become so synonymous with the Internet search that it may no longer matter how good Cuil or any other challenger is. “Search has become as much about branding as anything else,” he said. “I doubt [Cuil] will be keeping anyone at Google awake at night.”

I’d be curious to hear what CIOs find when they Google and Cuil their own names. Which search engine gives you a better face? Are you cool with Cuil, or will you continue to be gaga over Google?

6  Comments on this Post

 
There was an error processing your information. Please try again later.
Thanks. We'll let you know when a new response is added.
Send me notifications when other members comment.

REGISTER or login:

Forgot Password?
By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States. Privacy
  • Rachel Lebeaux
    when I searched on my name in quotes on cuil - 4 entries were found, of which two were actually me, on altavista many more entries were found, not sure I see how cuil is better - Cuil missed linkedin, spoke, plaxo, UNF council and others. Cuil has a ways to go... when searching on google - 8 entries were loaded on the first page. I rarely go beyond the first page so i doubt Cuil will be my first choice.
    0 pointsBadges:
    report
  • Rachel Lebeaux
    Don't use this yet - the virus folk are attacking cuil - the first link I tried brought up Power Anti Virus 2009 messages all over my machine - I wait to see if this causes damage, despite being vigilant and declining the offer to install such infectious items, my colleague suffered dramtically with probably the same virus going round call Antivirus 2008
    0 pointsBadges:
    report
  • John t
    I searched for three small sites I am involved with and all show on Google searches on the top page I dint find one of them on the top thirteen pages of any search No good for me at the moment perhaps too early to find smaller specialist sites
    5 pointsBadges:
    report
  • Rachel Lebeaux
    I really like the idea, but similar to other reviews has quite a bit to go yet. Still I wish them well - only 10 years or so since google was the new kid on the block and only used by techno geeks.
    0 pointsBadges:
    report
  • Rachel Lebeaux
    I initially tried a couple aliases I use across the web, with Google I usually make up 50% of the returned hits. On Cuil I get nothing back. No problem, maybe a little too specific. So in a effort to give Cuil a easy target I searched for "Java String", Java being one of the most proliferated and wrote about languages on the net and String as being one of the most basic foundations of that language. The results text-wise were fine for the most part, however if I had a boss peering over my should he probably would have said Cuil was NSFW. The pictures displayed next to Java String Analyzer was of a beautiful lady in a lace bra, further down the screen we get some sexy panties. Yes, I did have safe search turned on. This said, and with the other searches I tried I can safely say I won't be bothering with Cuil until they get things figured out.
    0 pointsBadges:
    report
  • Rachel Lebeaux
    i just search my website across Cuil..the result is the same as google..i think so so.
    0 pointsBadges:
    report

Forgot Password

No problem! Submit your e-mail address below. We'll send you an e-mail containing your password.

Your password has been sent to: