The U.S. Patent & Trademark Office (USPTO) has invalidated the final four patents in Symantec’s infringement lawsuit against Veeam Software, making it difficult for Symantec to win its suit against the smaller vendor.
The USPTO patent trial and appeal board invalidated the first three patents involved in the suit in February, and has now ruled in Veeam’s favor on all seven disputed patents.
“The case is essentially over,” said Doug Hazelman, Veeam’s senior director of product strategy.
Veeam filed a joint status report with the U.S. District Court of Northern California Court last Friday advising that all asserted claims are invalid. Symantec can appeal the U.S. Patent & Trademark Office (USPTO) Patent Trial and Appeal Board’s ruling but a company spokesman said no decision has been made on whether to proceed
“Symantec is aware of the Patent Board rulings. We will continue to consider all of our legal options to protect our intellectual property,” Symantec spokesman Kurt Mumma said via email.
Symantec filed two lawsuits in 2012 in the Northern California court claiming that Veeam’s software infringed on seven Symantec storage, restore and backup patents. While preparing its court defense, Veeam also challenged the validity of the patents. The USPTO agreed with Veeam that the patents were obvious or anticipated by prior art, which means the technology involved was known or used before a patent was obtained.
Hazelman said while the lawsuits did not generate a great deal of attention, “some of our largest accounts were paying attention” and losing the lawsuit could have harmed its business.
Veeam said its bookings grew 22 percent in the first quarter of 2015 over last year, adding 10,800 paid customers in the quarter. For 2014, Veeam said its revenue grew 40 percent year over year to $389 million.
Perhaps looking to head off software-only hyper-convergence competitors down the road, Nutanix will make a free version of its software available beginning next month.
Nutanix will launch a public beta of its new Community Edition software June 8 during its .Next user conference. Nutanix has always maintained that all the value of its technology lies in the software, but it makes that software available only on appliances. Nutranix uses Supermicro hardware for its NX appliances. Dell also sells Nutanix software on PowerEdge servers through an OEM deal.
The Community Edition can run on x86 servers from Dell, Hewlett-Packard, Cisco, Supermicro and other hardware vendors. It can be deployed on one, three or four nodes. Nutanix will issue minimum hardware requirements to run the software. The Community Edition will run on all-flash hardware, or in a hybrid configuration with SSDs and hard disk drives.
Nutanix requires a minimum of a three-node configuration for its paid product, but will allow the free edition to run on one node for testing.
The Community Edition only runs with KVM hypervisors, unlike the NX appliances that also support VMware ESX and Microsoft Hyper-V. If users like the free software, they cannot upgrade it to a licensed version of the product. They must buy a new appliance form Nutanix or Dell. There will be no official support for the free product from Nutanix, but users can seek help through the Nutanix NEXT online community.
However, the Community Edition has all the features of a paid Nutanix appliance.
“It’s our entire feature set. Customers are empowered to take full advantage, there are no limitations to applications or workloads they can run,” said Greg Smith, Nutanix senior director of product and technical marketing.
Smith said he expects the free edition to be popular among application developers and prospective channel partners who want to test the technology before committing to the paid version.
While hyper-converged pioneers Nutanix and SimpliVity bundle their software on appliances, others sell software that can be packaged on commodity hardware by customers or channel partners. VMware is the major software-only rival to Nutanix with its Virtual SAN (VSAN) that is sold by major vendors through an EVO:RAIL OEM program. Maxta also sells hyper-converged software.
Still, Smith said the vendor is sticking with the appliance model for its commercial products for now. “Right now, [a software-only paid version] is not in our plan,” he said. “Customers tell us they like the convenience of appliances. Our efforts are devoted to making our appliances and Dell appliances as easy to use as possible.”
Quantum’s forecast for the next year includes more StorNext and scale-out archiving products, sales and vertical markets.
The sales bump has already started. Quantum last week reported its scale-out storage – which includes StorNext – increased 116 percent to $31.7 million for last quarter and grew 74 percent to $102.4 million for the year. That led overall Quantum revenue growth of 15 percent for the quarter while its total revenue for the full fiscal 2015 year was flat with the previous year.
CEO Jon Gacek said more StorNext products are coming soon during the vendor’s earnings call last week.
“We will further expand our portfolio of full StorNext solutions with a goal of enhancing the customer experience,” Gacek said. “We will also continue to focus on increasing our StorNext 5 appliance footprint with large install base customers by employing more disk, object, tape and cloud storage.”
The product expansion will come on top of the Artico NAS and larger capacity Lattus nodes that Quantum rolled out last month.
Gacek said he expects a surge in Quantum’s video surveillance customer base over the next year. Most of StorNext’s revenue today comes from the media and entertainment industry, but Gacek sees surveillance as ripe for growth because of requirements for long-term retention and larger capacity video formats.
“Surveillance has generally been a low-cost NAS market for storage,” Gacek said. “Surveillance cameras didn’t have a lot of resolution and there was a short retention period. Now the cameras are going high definition, there’s a lot more data, people are doing analytics on it, and the retention periods are enormous.”
He said close to an exabyte of data is captured in the world every day. Besides StorNext, Gacek sees Quantum’s Lattus object storage and even its core tape business playing big roles in the surveillance market. Quantum is also going after network forensics, government intelligence and high performance computing with its scale out platforms. Data for all of those markets must be ingested fast, retained indefinitely and accessed whenever needed.
Quantum forecasted a 50 percent increase in scale-out revenue this quarter over last year. For the full year, its guidance calls for a 50 percent bump in scale-out storage revenue.
Quantum’s DXi deduplication and disk backup platform increased 30 percent year over year to $25.2 million last quarter and increased 120 percent to $88.2 million for the year. StorNext and DXi helped Quantum overcome a decrease in tape sales to hold revenue at the same level as 2014. For the fiscal year, Quantum reported a net income of $16.8 million compared to a loss of $21.5 million the previous year.
“Fiscal 2015 was a key turning point for Quantum,” Gacek said.
Nimble Storage announced that SAP certified its Adaptive Flash CS500 and CS700 arrays for the SAP HANA in-memory database management system. The San Jose, California, storage startup sells hybrid arrays that combine solid-state and hard-disk drives and offer features such as performance monitoring, scale-out clustering and triple-parity RAID.
Nimble’s SAP certification opened the door for the company to participate in the HANA tailored data center integration (TDI) program, which lets customers use their existing hardware and infrastructure components for HANA deployments. Nimble developed a SmartStack integrated infrastructure offering built on Cisco’s Unified Computing System (UCS), tested and validated to work with SAP HANA.
“HANA is a pretty complex workload, and figuring out the sizing and the deployment guidelines can be pretty challenging,” said Radhika Krishnan, vice president of product marketing and alliances at Nimble. “What we’ve done working with Cisco is provide a reference architecture that outlines all the best practices as well as the deployment specs, the guidelines, that customers require.”
Cisco’s “build and price” site for SAP’s Business Suite for HANA (S/4HANA) lists Nimble as well as EMC, IBM and NetApp as recommended storage configurations for small, medium and large S/4HANA production environments.
“That’s essentially intended to help customers accelerate the pace at which they can get their HANA environments provisioned,” said Krishnan. “And it’s also to eliminate a part of the risk involved in the process. Oftentimes these are projects that take multiple months, and we’re trying to accelerate that whole cycle by providing off-the-shelf guidelines and reference architectures.”
In order to get the SAP certification, Nimble had to run tests to demonstrate that its systems had the performance and reliability characteristics to host mission-critical tier 1 workloads, according to Krishnan. She said that Nimble started the certification process last October.
Krishnan claimed one advantage of the Nimble-Cisco combination with SAP HANA is the ability to accommodate growth over time in a “safe, gradual manner without any kind of disruption to the application,” as well as lower power and cooling requirements than some of the other options on Cisco’s recommended list. She estimated that Nimble has several dozen customers using SAP with its storage systems.
LAS VEGAS — You don’t usually associate EMC with open or free, but at EMC World today the vendor said it is making ViPR an open-source project and is offering a free non-production version of its ScaleIO storage software.
Project CoprHD will make the storage automation and control functionality code for ViPR Controller open for community-driven development. EMC plans to make CoprHD available on GitHub in June, licensed under the Mozilla Public License 2.0 (MPL 2.0).
It will enable customers, partners, developers and other storage vendors to contribute new services and applications for ViPR. ViPR automates storage management and can virtualize EMC and third-party storage into one pool. EMC would like to draw more developers into working on ViPR and would welcome the embrace of the OpenStack community.
Free ScaleIO is an unlimited capacity version of EMC’s shared block storage software available for non-production use. EMC also launched the ScaleIO Product Community on the EMC Community Network (ECN). Customers, partners and developers can download EMC ScaleIO software from ECN. EMC’s goal is to tempt customers with the free version, and convince them to upgrade to a paid production license.
Skeptics might say EMC is opening ViPR because it can’t get third parties to develop to it, but EMC president of products Jeremy Burton said it is part of new strategy.
“This is a big philosophical shift inside EMC,” Burton said. “I don’t think we could have done this a few years ago. We’re making our customers part of our development process.”
Burton said he would like to see ViPR embraced by the OpenStack community.
“We would rather contribute to existing OpenStack projects than stand alone,” he said. “If we could move ViPR to be more part of OpenStack, that would be the preferred route.
C.J. Desai, president of EMC’s emerging technologies division, said he expects more EMC software to be made available for developers.
“This is the beginning, its step number one,” he said.
Jay Kidd is retiring as NetApp CTO, although not necessarily ending his career.
In a blog post today, Kidd said he is leaving NetApp after 10 years. Kidd wrote that he is leaving corporate life and “will shift my time to pursue more personal interests and delve more deeply into the areas of advising and investing.” That hints he might become involved with startup companies.
NetApp will not replace Kidd as CTO, and it sounds like the vendor will take a CTO by committee approach. Kidd wrote that the job has likely become too big for one person.
“The role of the CTO in a company the size of NetApp is too broad to be done by a single individual, and a ‘CTO Community’ evolves which includes people both in the CTO office as well as in other parts of the organization,” he wrote. “It includes product architects, technology researchers, technical community leaders, market and industry researchers, technical spokespeople and a host of other disciplines.”
He added that he could not “imagine a better place to work” than NetApp and will always be an advocate for the company. Before joining NetApp in 2005 as SVP of emerging products, Kidd spent six years at Fibre Channel switch vendor Brocade as VP of product management and CTO.
Kidd’s departure comes with NetApp in a long sales slump, with a string of year-to-year revenue declines. The vendor laid off more than 1,000 workers since 2013. Financial analyst firm Piper downgraded NetApp’s stock last month, claiming flash storage and cloud storage providers are cutting into its sales.
LAS VEGAS — Hitachi Data Systems opened its HDS Connect conference today with smaller versions of its flagship Virtual Storage Platform (VSP) storage array and two hyper-converged systems. The hyper-converged systems include one based on HDS technology and the other on VMware’s EVO:RAIL.
HDS is extending the VSP that it launched a year ago downwards with dual-controller, smaller arrays. The first VSP – the G1000 – can support 16 controllers and scale to 4.5 PB in a 10U rack. It continued HDS’ tradition of high-end enterprise arrays.
The new arrays include a 3u VSP G200 and 5u VSP G400, G600 and G800 models. They range in capacity from 1 PB on the G200 to 5.7 PB on the G800.
Like the G1000, the new systems can use Hitachi’s proprietary flash module drives (FMDs), which come in 1.6 TB and 3.2 TB capacities. The G200 supports 264 FMDs, the G400 480, the G600 720 and the G800 1,440. The G1000 holds 578 FMDs.
The new VSP arrays use the same Hitachi Storage Virtualization Operating System (SVOS) as the G1000. SVOS allows other vendors’ storage to be virtualized behind the VSP arrays, handles management features such as non-disruptive data migration and includes a native global active device feature that provides active-active clusters across data centers without requiring a separate storage appliance.
The VSP arrays support Fibre Channel and iSCSI storage natively, and connect to Hitachi NAS file arrays for unified storage.
While the G1000 is aimed at large enterprises, HDS will market the smaller systems as ways for midmarket companies to consolidate virtual server block and file workloads.
“The VSP high end was always unreachable for some customers,” said Bob Madaio, HDS senior director of product marketing. “You have to understand the needs of the application and not assume it’s one-size fits all.”
Madaio said while the software is the same across all VSP arrays, the new systems use Intel-based controllers instead of an HDs proprietary architecture.
The G200, G400 and G600 arrays are available today with the G800 expected later this year.
The hyper-converged systems are part of Hitachi’s UCP convergence family. Madaio described the new Hitachi Scale-Out Platform (HSP) as “hyper-convergence for the analytics world.” HDS positions HSP as a scale-out platform for Hadoop environments, allowing customers to analyze data in place so they don’t have to move large data sets to perform analytics functions. It uses Hitachi servers along with KVM hypervisors and HDS storage management software.
HDS also launched the Hitachi UCP 1000 for VMware EVO:RAIL that uses VMware’s Virtual SAN (VSAN) hyper-converged software. HDS said it would be an EVO:RAIL partner last year, but the UCP 1000 is its first product based on the VMware partnership. HDS sees the UCP 1000 and the new UCP 2000 – which combines Hitachi servers with the VSP G200 – as SMB or remote office storage.
We’ll have more on these and other news from HDS Connect over the next several days on SearchVirtualStorage.com.
EMC came up $75 million short of its projected storage revenue last quarter, according to its Wednesday earnings report.
No big surprise there. EMC and other large storage vendors have struggled to increase revenue and hit their forecasts over the past year or so. And as always is the case whenever that happens, EMC executives gave reasons for the failure. They pointed to customers waiting for the new Data Domain backup system, internal problems caused by recent layoffs, and geopolitics in Russia and China that dampened sales.
There is another reason, though, that has nothing to do with EMC’s products or sales force, or geopolitics. There is a fundamental shift in the type of storage people are buying that has a negative effect on legacy storage vendors. So while EMC, NetApp, IBM, Hewlett-Packard and Hitachi Data Systems have struggled to grow revenues, smaller vendors such as Nutanix, Nimble Storage, Pure Storage and Tintri have picked up the slack with the types of storage systems that didn’t exist five years ago.
This trend is not lost on EMC, which has moved faster than other large vendors to adjust to the changes. It has acquired or developed all-flash, hyper-converged, cloud, and big data systems that are replacing its legacy arrays in deals. A drill-down on its sales last quarter shows how that transformation is playing out.
EMC’s high-end storage – its flagship VMAX platform – fell seven percent year-over-year to $871 million. That follows at 13 percent year-over-year drop in the previous quarter.
Backup and recovery products – a large growth area for years after EMC’s 2009 acquisition of Data Domain – dropped 11 percent to $1.3 billion last quarter. But other storage platforms — including Xtremio, Isilon scale-out NAS, ScaleIO converged infrastructure, ViPR software-defined storage and Elastic Cloud Storage — combined to grow more than 15 percent to $1.5 billion to help pick up the slack. Overall, EMC’s storage revenue of $3.7 billion for the quarter was down less than 1 percent from last year.
“We were disappointed that we a bit short of our revenue plan,” EMC federation CEO Joe Tucci said of the quarter.
We’re seeing the newer technologies replacing the old in many cases. David Goulden, CEO of EMC’s Information Infrastructure (storage) group, said revenue from XtremIO all-flash storage more than doubled from a year ago. Goulden said XtremIO is on track for more than $1 billion in bookings in 2015. About one-third of its revenue comes from replacing workloads that customers previously ran on other EMC storage, with another third from previous EMC customers running new workloads and the other third from customers new to EMC.
Goulden blamed EMC’s drastic backup revenue drop on customers waiting for the new high-end Data Domain disk backup system, which will launch during EMC World next month. That should help but there is a good chance EMC’s heady backup growth is over. EMC already offers customers a way to back up directly to arrays with its ProtectPoint software, and it may bring out a virtual appliance version of Data Domain that will sell for less money than the large disk appliances. These are more examples of how new technologies are changing the way people buy storage.
“There is a huge inextricable linked business and IT transformation taking place right now,” Tucci said.
The challenge for EMC and other large storage vendors is to keep up with that change. Tucci and Goulden pointed to new other product launches coming at EMC World including XtremIO enhancements, software defined storage, converged infrastructure, and data lake solutions involving EMC storage and its Pivotal cloud and analytics division. The vendor will also fill in some of the blanks around its DSSD in-memory flash storage, expected to ship in late 2015. Unlike the Data Domain backup target, none of these are traditional storage products.
Las Vegas – The storage presence at the National Association of Broadcasters (NAB) show last week continued to grow due to the increasing demand to store files in the media and entertainment market. The increase in camera resolution to 4K and beyond expands the size of captured video data. The trend to retain that data on disk rather than on reels of video tape makes the digital inventory even greater.
To meet this demand, storage vendors have created specialized offerings to optimize use in media and entertainment. These are on display at the NAB show, and the Evaluator Group met with many of them there. Here is a summary of those meetings:
The Crossroads StrongBox gateway is integrated by storage vendor partners into their products for moving data to tape using the Amazon S3 protocol. The system can also replicate data to another StrongBox. Additional capabilities include performance tuning to decide what data needs to remain on primary storage.
DataDirect Networks (DDN)
DDN sells high performance storage for post-production and large capacity scaling object storage for retention of video data At NAB, DDN demonstrated its new MediaScaler system with front end connectivity that includes Fibre Channel and InfiniBand in addition to file and object (S3) connections over Ethernet . The MediaScaler, which can handle multiple data streams, was developed by DDN in collaboration with Red Bull Media. DDN also sells Web Object Scaler (WOS), an object storage system with support for files. WOS is used as a repository for the M&E market.
Dot Hill has video editing and processing system partners that integrate the vendor’s high performance block storage systems in their offerings. At the NAB conference, Dot Hill announced a new distributor agreement with Quantum, which was already a Dot Hill OEM parnter.
The EMC Isilon system has been effectively used as a large scaling NAS system in the M&E market. As a market leader in storage, EMC continues to invest in Isilon R&D and has delivered on new features and capabilities. EMC will add capabilities at EMC World next month for Isilon, including features that enhance M&E usage.
HGST offers the Active Archive System as a packaged solution with HGST 8TB helium-filled disks and the Amplidata object software HGST acquired recently. HGST will continue to support previous OEMs of Amplidata – including Quantum — and will deliver new packaged solutions using HGST storage devices. The current Active Archive System has 4.7PB in a single rack and can scale in multi-rack configuration as an object storage system with an optional file gateway device.
Hitachi Data Systems (HDS)
HDS has become a major player in the media and entertainment space with HNAS and Hitachi Content Platform (HCP). HNAS has been used for post-production and transcoding and HCP as the media content repository. In many cases with large media companies, HNAS and HCP are used in concert for a complete system for editing, transcoding, and broadcast.
Imation focuses on safeguarding data throughout the lifecycle with the Secure Data Movement Architecture. Elements in the architecture include the Assureon archiving system and Ironkey encryption lock and key. Additions include administration security and a dual authentication option. Imation has a focused solution to handle data movement in the M&E space and the notable security breaches that have occurred with leaking of videos, Imation has a focused solution.
The LTO Consortium, which promotes the standard LTO tape format (drives and media), uses NAB to showcase the LTO roadmap and use cases. This year, the discussion was around the upcoming release of LTO-7, scheduled for later this year. The specifications include 6TB per cartridge and 300MB per second bandwidth.
NetApp’s StorageGrid WebScale has long had a presence in healthcare as a large-capacity object storage system. Now NetApp is also targeting the system for M&E with its file interfaces. Part of that strategy is a partnership with Spectra Logic that involves using Spectra’s Black Pearl archiving appliance as a target for data from a StorageGrid WebScale storage system.
Object Matrix, based in Cardiff, Wales, has an object storage system that includes the vendor’s software running on commodity hardware. The system’s built-in search and metadata capabilities integrate into existing workflows. Tape can serve as a deep archive with Object Matrix. Notably, Object Matrix works with Avid asset management software for broadcasters.
Promise’s media and entertainment products include removable media interconnect devices, Fibre Channel to Thunderbolt linkage devices, and enterprise storage systems to store file, object, and block (iSCSI) data. The VSky enterprise systems can scale out and up to large capacity for the M&E market as well as video surveillance. A gateway NAS system is also available. The Vess R2600 Pro system is focused on post production editing.
Quantum has been aggressively building out its StoreNext file system that has been successful in the M&E space. It recently added the Q-Cloud Archive was that allows StorNext to serve as the front tend for storing information on a public cloud. A primary value for Quantum is that StorNext gives customers a single interface for storage. Quantum this month released the Artico NAS system that acts as a local NAS device and a gateway to cloud storage for large capacity.
Qumulo offers software to provide a scale out file system (Qumulo Scalable File System) that can handle the large number of files required in many market segments. The vendor demonstrated storage of 10 billion files with a minimal hardware configuration at its booth. As with most vendors that offer their software as “software defined storage,” Qumulo sells its solution with hardware. The value message for Qumulo is about storing information about the data stored as part of the system for more effective management and access.
Signiant provides software for high performance file movement over long distances. The software is licensed and can be resident or used as software as a service. The M&E market traditionally moves large amounts of video data for editing and other operations, making it a good opportunity for Signiant.
The media and entertainment market historically has used digital magnetic tape for interchange and in large libraries as media repositories. Spectra Logic sells tape libraries in various sizes across the M&E market, but used this year’s NAB conference to introduce a new feature for the Black Pearl gateway device. The Black Pearl system allows data to be written to it using the Amazon S3 protocol and then stored on tape in a library. This year Spectra added a prototype offering of the Black Pearl as an S3 target for NetApp’s StorageGrid WebScale.
(Randy Kerns is Senior Strategist at Evaluator Group, an IT analyst firm).
SanDisk became the PCIe flash market leader with its 2014 acquisition of server-side flash pioneer Fusion-io. Less than a year later, there is a lot less to that market and that is having a negative impact on SanDisk’s bottom line.
SanDisk’s $1.32 billion in revenue last quarter was below its initial forecast of from $1.4 billion to $1.45 billion, and down 12 percent from last year and 23 percent from the previous quarter. It cut its full year guidance for 2015 to a range of $5.4 billion to $5.7 billion from previous guidance of $6.5 billion to $6.8 billion. The new annual forecast would bring SanDisk revenue below its $6.6 billion from 2014. To compensate for the loss of revenue, the flash vendor announced it will reduce its workforce by around five percent.
Two factors hit SanDisk hard last quarter. It sold a lot less SAS solid state drives (SSDs) than expected, and larger customers started moving off PCIe cards onto 2 TB SATA SSDs. SanDisk CEO Sanjay Mehrotra blamed the SAS product problems on “execution” issues largely related to product qualifications. He attributed the PCIe problem and companies finding SATA drives good enough at a lower price. SanDisk hopes to change that with a new PCIe platform coming this month.
“Our results as well as 2015 revenue estimates for our Fusion-io PCIe solutions are significantly below our original plan,” Mehrotra said on the vendor’s earnings call Wednesday. “We are seeing a substantial portion of the PCIe [market] moving to lower cost solutions using enterprise SATA SSDs.”
“We expect to fully remain the market share leader [in PCIe], and we plan to address that in the 2016 timeframe with solutions using our captive memory as well as when we introduce NVMe solutions,” he said.
In the meantime, there will be pain and cuts at the company.