I cannot answer this question for you but I think a good option would be to talk to some recruiters/headhunters and get their perspectives on this. My thoughts on this are that any education is good but real world experience is best. I would take a look at these degrees from this angle and then make the decision about which one gets you the most experience in a broad segment of these skills. And believe me, there is a lot of knowledge and skills that are required to be a good security professional.
Hope this helps!
In the IT trenches? So am I – read my <a href=”http://itknowledgeexchange.techtarget.com/it-trenches”>IT-Trenches blog</a>