I have 2 servers at work that do not have the correct WSUS settings from the GPO. When I run the RSOP it does show that the GPO has applied correctly, but when I check the settings in the control panel the do not match. However it still doesn't allow me to change it as it says it is controlled by the systems administrator.
So these two servers are currently operating with the setting to install updates automatically and reboot automatically, where the GPO says that they should only download and notify.
All of our other servers (70+) are operating properly. They are all in the same AD container and all have the same GPO settings linked to them.