Adventures in Data Center Automation

Mar 10 2009   1:24AM GMT

IT Process Orchestration Revisited



Posted by: Ryan Shopp
BMC, CA, data center automation, enigmatic, HP Software, IBM Tivoli, IT Process Automation, iwave, LANDesk, NetIQ, Opalis, RBA, Run Book Automation, stratavis, uc4

I decided it was time to review and make an update to the IT Process Automation, Process Orchestration, Run Book Automation, Data Center Automation, IT Process Integration, or whatever name each vendor, customer or analysts choose to call it.  Since my last update to the Data Center Automation Blueprint (DCAB) there have been some industry changes with some vendors going a different direction, other being acquired, etc.

A quick review of this space from the DCAB is first up.

Process Orchestration
Description – Cross-silo automation for mundane manual or high occurrence tasks. The capabilities are focused around helping individual technology domains (e.g., network, windows, unix, database, etc) communicate and collaborate to automate tasks that before required numerous people and passing around a trouble ticket.

Top 5 Capabilities
1) Drag/Drop graphical interface for designing process workflows
2) Common, normalized Data Model of common/primary attributes
3) Library of pre-defined, re-usable actions/triggers/processes for usage out-of-the-box (bigger the better – even a community that shares is a plus)
4) Policy/Desired-state engine driving things
5). Sandbox, simulator to help test workflows without impacting actual resources/instances within the production enterprise.

The Vendors
BMC (formerly RealOps)
CA (formerly Optinuity)
Enigmatec
HP (formerly Opsware, formerly iConclude)
IBM (formerly Micromuse Impact)
iWave Software
LANDesk (Process Manager product)
NetIQ (Aegis product)
Opalis
Stratavia
UC4 Software

So since the last update, what has been going on in the space….

It’s interesting to see Stratavia tweaking their company positioning as the “independent” choice.  Makes sense considering we’ve had a wave of consolidation with the big 4 ensuring they have coverage for this functional area, and also other well known (larger) management vendors (LANDesk & NetIQ) adding capabilities.

Optinuity was acquired by CA in October and naturally that changed some things for Opalis which had a previous OEM relationship with CA.  Opalis in turn also trumpets the “independent” choice and has gone further into talking about how this doesn’t serve the customers since those vendors are using those acquisitions to bring their own products together and not looking at it from a heterogenous standpoint of I have 5 products from 3 vendors and I need them all to work together smoothly.  One last area that I need to do some more exploring around is something I felt a year ago would eventually happen and the lines would start blurring between Business Process Management (BPM) solutions and IT Process Orchestration.  The are starting to compare/contract with BPM and also talk more Business Intelligence (BI) messaging.  It’s nice to see a vendor lay out in plain site some recommended evaluation criteria for all customers and even competitors to see…great way to set the bar.

Those are a couple key things i’m seeing at a glance…what else is going on out there.  Who else is in the space these days, what is their key differentiator versus the players listed above.  Drop you comments in below if you a vendor or a customer using one of these vendors or another one I don’t have listed.  I’ll make updates to the DCAB if it’s appropriate.

Comment on this Post

Leave a comment:

Ayehu  |   Mar 10, 2009  10:13 AM (GMT)

Hi Ryan,

Please take a look at http://www.Ayehu.com.

Thanks,
Gabby Nizri
Founder, CEO.
Gabby@ayehu.com


 

Ryan Shopp  |   Mar 11, 2009  1:47 AM (GMT)

Gabby- thanks for sharing…. do you have a more comprehensive list of what out-of-the-box connectors / workflows that are offering (only saw a few names mentioned on your site)? Also what would you say are Ayehu’s key differentiators are vs. the other independent players mentioned above? Thanks, Ryan


 

DavidShephard  |   Mar 11, 2009  5:05 PM (GMT)

Hi Ryan,

Thank you for the NetIQ tag/link and thought you might be interested in the [A href="http://community.netiq.com/blogs/it_process_automation/default.aspx"]Automate This![/A] blog that we started up recently.

Our user community will be interested in your post and hopefully you will receive an unbiased comment or two from them.

Regards
David


 

AutomationFabric  |   Aug 7, 2009  12:56 PM (GMT)

Thanks for the update and mention of Opalis. I did some blogging on the BPM/ITPA question recently. Have a look http://budurl.com/ITPAvsBPA.
Gartner also has RBA/ITPA at the top of the Peak of Inflated Expectations. I blogged on how to avoid the Trough of Disillusionment here http://budurl.com/avoidTrough
Forrester is also talking about the ITPA market being at a tipping point. This is going to be an even more interesting area over the next year. Thank you for keeping an eye on it.