Posted by: Charles Denyer
assessments, audits, charles denyer, cpa firm, payment card industry data security standards, PCI DSS, PCI DSS Level 1 compliance, report on compliance, ROC, sas 70 type ii audit
SAS 70 audits, especially Type II reports and PCI DSS Level 1 Report on Compliance (ROC) assessments are dominating today’s regulatory compliance arena. Painfully, as a SAS 70 auditor and a PCI DSS assessor, I keep hearing people talk about these two compliance initiatives as if they are one in the same…..stop…….they are different.
Don’t get me wrong, efficiencies of scale can be had and I will talk about that in a later post, but generally speaking, this is like comparing apples to oranges. Here’s why.
The SAS 70 auditing standard is a loose and flexible standard, allowing auditors to employ (and they do) various methodologies, benchmarks, standards, and frameworks for SAS 70 audits.
The Payment Card Industry Data Security Standards (PCI DSS) requirements are much more rigid, less open to interpretation, if you will.
Ever read one SAS 70 report from a CPA firm then picked up another report on a similar company that was issued by another CPA firm? If so, you probably noticed they looked and “read” quite differently. Well, no surprise there.
Now, try that with a PCI DSS Level 1 Report on Compliance. Sure, they won’t be identical, but they’ll be much more similar than the two SAS 70 audits.