Enterprise IT Watch Blog

Oct 21 2010   8:00AM GMT

The Interop user revolt against cloudy clouds: More solutions, less pixie dust!

Melanie Yarbrough Profile: MelanieYarbrough

I made the trek to Interop New York yesterday morning, and jumped right into my first breakout session: Measuring Cloud Performance. I know what you’re thinking: More marketing mumbo jumbo on the buzz word that’s lost all meaning. And there were definitely moments of that, especially with a VP of product marketing on the panel, but during the predominantly question-and-answer forum, there were also moments of frustration and frank discussion on the state of the cloud computing industry.

The Panel

Moderated by Hooman Beheshti, a VP at Strangeloop, the discussion was led by panelists David Link, CEO of ScienceLogic; Randy Bias, CEO of Cloudscaling; Jason Read, founder of CloudHarmony; Russell Rothstein, VP of Product Marketing for OpTier; and Alex Polvi, CEO of CloudKick.

The Hard-Hitting Cloud Questions: What is Cloud Performance?

Beheshti began the conversation with what seems to be the standard jumping off point for any discussion concerning cloud: What the heck is it? The panelists gave a few answers: The difference of app performance when moving to a multi-tenant environment. Paying attention to the performance changes that happen based on shared resources and oversubscription. Understanding the latency that happens between the business and the cloud and the cloud and the customer.

That’s all well and good, but not specific enough for the audience members actively seeking a move to the cloud. The concern that seemed to be irking most of the audience was the lack of visibility into the cloud. One man spoke up: He wants to move his disaster recovery function from a failover site to the cloud, but felt he was getting the runaround from cloud providers. He wanted to know how to get the big picture of service providers’ capabilities to ensure acceptable end-user performance through setting up SLAs.

The general attitude of the panel was that you can’t, really. David Link pointed out that that’s where a lot of service providers fail. Amazon Web Services’ API basically provides a description of their services and configuration data and, for a fee, some performance data. For the most part, however, analytics are widely unavailable.

I caught up with the attendee who asked the original question about failing over his disaster recovery functions, and asked him what’s got him the most frustrated. “It’s frustrating to feel like you’re looking for an infrastructure rather than a solution,” he said, adding that his law firm with about 1500 users can’t meet the overhype of cloud computing.

When I brought this up with Randy Bias, he responded that a lot of people looking into the cloud don’t fully understand all that it entails. “There’s no pixie dust,” Bias said. “There’s no cloud dust that’s going to magically make your application run better.” With all of the hype that cloud receives, it’s become a sort of computing Second Coming, and Bias says to snap out of it. The main challenge is that leadership doesn’t understand the difference between the infrastructure they’re running now and the cloud. They want to move these enterprise applications, complete with their flaws, expecting the cloud to make them run better, not understanding that a move to the cloud might first include migrating to SaaS or building a new app whose architecture can work properly within the cloud.

Dealing with service providers’ opacity

One critique of service providers in the cloud is the lack of visibility into their operations. Bias suggests utilizing third-party offerings from companies such as panelist’s Alex Polvi’s CloudKick to build upon services like Amazon Web Services that Amazon can’t provide itself.

Bias’s suggestion for signing up with a cloud provider that doesn’t offer full visibility? Find someone who can provide services such as reverse mapping to allow you to compare your own performance with other users with similar workloads. He focused on the “immaturity” of the cloud’s ability to respond to performance issues: “Automated correlation and response is the key…the capability exists, maturity is the issue.”

So what does that mean for the rest of us?

Cloud computing has an almost cult following with evangelists preaching the economic benefits of migrating to the cloud. The bottom line at Interop New York? Great reaping follows great sowing. Depending on the type of workload the enterprise wants to deploy in the cloud, there are more factors to consider rather than simply which service provider to use. At this point in the industry’s development, unfortunately, there’s still a lot of heavy lifting left on the shoulders of the user.

Melanie Yarbrough is the assistant community editor at ITKnowledgeExchange.com. Follow her on Twitter or send her an email at Melanie@ITKnowledgeExchange.com.

4  Comments on this Post

 
There was an error processing your information. Please try again later.
Thanks. We'll let you know when a new response is added.
Send me notifications when other members comment.

REGISTER or login:

Forgot Password?
By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States. Privacy
  • MelanieYarbrough
    [...] cloud!” Now Microsoft isn’t alone here. As implied above, this year Interop was reportedly heavy on cloud computing sessions and vendor exhibits. VMworld 2010 was filled with news around vCloud Director and the company’s [...]
    0 pointsBadges:
    report
  • MelanieYarbrough
    [...] just as Randy Bias says that the cloud isn’t a solo services deal, people want to know to what extent additional services are available to help in the [...]
    0 pointsBadges:
    report
  • MelanieYarbrough
    [...] the end of its marketing heyday will allow for a more realistic approach by users. Cloud evangelist Randy Bias already takes a pragmatic approach to the cloud, offering this advice: Make sure your app is performing properly on your current infrastructure [...]
    0 pointsBadges:
    report
  • MelanieYarbrough
    [...] at OpTier and Alex Polvi, CEO of CloudKick. In a bit of a unique format, the panel agreed to have a straight question and answer session (as opposed to traditional presentation slides) and were able to field some interesting questions [...]
    0 pointsBadges:
    report

Forgot Password

No problem! Submit your e-mail address below. We'll send you an e-mail containing your password.

Your password has been sent to: